Nuclear Accidents

The bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the atmospheric bomb tests carried out in the 1950’s and ‘60’s were the tragic results of deliberate and premeditated actions. Many of the releases of radiation from the military or civilian nuclear industry, however, are well and truly accidental.

Nuclear accidents in the military date back to the early days of the arms race, when the major powers – the United States, the Soviet Union and Great Britain – developed their atomic weapons in the greatest possible secrecy (*).

1950, Mayak: a military accident:
In the 1950’s, the earliest days of the Mayak reactor, the waters of the Kyzyltash lake were directly used to cool the core of the plutonium-producing reactors. Radioactive waste pumped into the Techa river over the following years was responsible for serious environmental contaminations. There is an interesting contrast to be noted here between military and civilian nuclear accidents: on one hand, serious accidents such as Mayak have been covered up for years by secrecy, whereas there was tremendous media hype around the Three Mile Island accident, which caused more fear than actual damage.
DR(Source Richard Wilson et al)

These early accidents were the result of a combination of lack of experience, ignorance of many relevant phenomena, and a general disregard for necessary safety precautions. Possible environmental consequences did not rate very highly when compared to the strategic objectives. Many tests, especially in the Soviet Union, were carried out in previously unspoiled natural areas. This seemed the obvious way to minimise the danger caused by the generally lax safety protocols.

These accidents were due to a lack of experience that onehad at the time, to ignorance of certain phenomena and also to a lack of precautions. Environmental preoccupations did not carried much weight against strategic objectives.

It was this mindset that led to the contamination of the Techa River in the Southern Urals. Radioactive waste stockpiled in lakes at the Mayak reactor site leaked out when the cold caused the containers to burst, and the area suffered from the consequences from 1949 to 1956.

IThe 1957 graphite fire at the Windscale power plant (better known as the Sellafield reactor) would have had far less dramatic consequences if the English engineers had known about the Wigner Effect, a then comparatively recently-discovered phenomenon. Many of these accidents which took place on old military sites were understandably late to emerge – especially those which took place in the old Soviet Union.

Three Mile Island: a civilian accident:
The mass evacuation following the TMI accident in 1979 coincided with the release of ‘The China Syndrome’, a nuclear disaster movie starring Jack Lemmon, Jane Fonda and Michael Douglas. In the film, journalists report on events in a top secret nuclear reactor while the authorities attempt to suppress the story. The title comes from a belief, humorously referred to in the film, that if an American nuclear reactor melts down it will melt through the Earth and come out on the other side, in China! In the real-life accident, fusion did take place in the reactor’s centre, but the surrounding layers remained intact. The circles on the map above show the extent of the feared fallout that never took place.
The civilian nuclear industry profited from many of the painful lessons teached by the military accidents. A security-oriented culture began to develop, and the nuclear industry took pride in the lack of any major accidents. The 1977 Three Mile Island accident and especially the 1986 Chernobyl disaster, however, shook the public’s confidence in this new technology.

The Three Mile Island accident, which took place near Washington DC, resulted in the destruction of a reactor but fortunately caused comparatively little environmental contamination. The traumatic effect it left on the American psyche was mainly due to the precautionary displacement of several hundreds of thousands of people. The security systems which prevented the Three Mile Island accident from transforming into anything more serious were also in place on the Chernobyl reactor. The dramatic consequences of Chernobyl were largely the result of the tragic deactivation of the security systems, and the giant radioactive cloud which has come to represent the Soviet disaster would otherwise have been avoided.

The last accident of Fukushima was triggered by the tsunami that devastated Japan in March 2011. The reactors at the plant were shut down but were their cooling systems were drowned. After Three Mile Island, the Japanese disaster has confirmed that defects of a proper cooling after shut down, as well as control of the chain reaction, could be the source of the more severe accidents.

Comparison of the major accidents
To effectively compare the major accidents with the fallout caused by nuclear testing, two factors have been considered: the activity of the most important radioisotopes released, and the surface area affected by the radiation (or the surface area evacuated as a result). In the case of Three Mile Island in 1979, for instance, while there was no permanent evacuation, some 100,000 people freely decided to temporarily vacate their own homes.

Reactor accidents are not the only ones that can take place, as shown by the 1999 TokaïMura criticality accident. Workers at this Japanese fuel reprocessing facility violated the security regulations that were in place, resulting in a comparatively minor accident nevertheless considered to be the third most serious in the history of nuclear technology.

Last but not least there are the accidents linked to radioactive sources used in medicine, industry, or in laboratories. The risk of exposure mandates a rigorous inspection system, but the small amounts of radioactivity involved limit the potential consequences of such accidents.

Access to page in french